Our friend Ogait has recently purchased an HP HDX16 (1060es, equivalent to the HP HDX16t in the US and to the 1010ea and 1005ea configurations in the UK) and, after more than one month of testing and daily usage, has been kind enough to write a review for you. Here you have:
Greetings to all internet users, this is Santiago Hors Fraile and I’m Technical Engineering in Computer Science and student of second module of that Engineering in Seville’s University.
One month and some days ago I got a HP Notebook HDX 16 Laptop after serveral months of hard searching of information to ensure that the laptop fits as much as possible to my requirements. Somehow, I was looking for a laptop complete in most ways. The main points I was looking for were:
- Good image and sound quality
- Ability to play medium GPU dependent games
- Good connectivity
- Comfortable keyboard
- Upper-intermediate CPU
- Cache memory and RAM as large as possible
- Acceptable customer service and a trusteable brand
Overall I was looking for a workstation which allows me to work with IDEs comfortably in all aspects and that could be used to enjoy in leisure time viewing films, TV and playing some games, priorizing the playability before graphic realism. Also I was needing a good Internet access wherever I was, due to the fact that it is a basic source of information for any Software developer (among many other things!)
Things I did not need were:
- Mobility.
- Long battery life.
- Large hard drive.
- Low cost.
As you can see I was needing a “desktop with less wires”, something easily portable from one desktop to another one (indoor mobility, or at maximum, short time displacements from home to the university or work).
Once you clearly know what I was looking for you must know that I was considering buying abroad (mainly from the USA and Germany), and that I was considering brands like Asus, Acer, Sony, Toshiba and other not so well known such as HUP. It would be impossible explain all I learned during 4 months of investigation about brands and models in this review, but I chose an HP finally, due to its good price-quality ratio.
These are the specifications:
- Processor: Intel Core 2 Duo P8400 (2.26 GHz).
- Memory: 4 GB DDR2.
- Graphics card: Nvidia GeForce 9600M GT (512 MB DDR2 dedicated).
- Hard disk: 320 GB a 5400 rpm.
- Monitor: 16″ a 1920×1080, glossy, double lamp.
- Optical drive: Blu-Ray ROM with DVD±R/RW double-layer SuperMulti.
- Wireless: 802.11b/g/n, Bluetooth.
- Operating System: Windows Vista Home Premium SP1 (64 bits).
- Extras: card reader, webcam with integrated mic, integrated number pad, Altec Lansing speakers with subwoofer.
- Weight: 3.35 kg
- Price: 1399 €.
Complete specifications (HP Spain).
I purchased it for 1232 euros using the following discounts:
- Student price
- First purchase at the HP site
- Sport backpack
I ordered it via web, and it was at home in two business days through the delivery company MRW (which even asked me the best hour to deliver it!). The box contained what you can see in the following pictures:
Parts:
- Multi-compartment HP backpack
- Bag for small items
- Power cord
- Quick start guide
- Detailed manual
- TDT Antenna
- Antenna adapter
- Battery
- Laptop
- Small remot
- Big remote
- Laptop sleeve (in the picture the laptop is inside)
1- Multi-compartment HP backpack
It is a very well made backpack where the laptop fits perfectly, having a lot more room for other things: more than 30 cm long when you extend it, 55 cm tall and 40 cm wide. The fabric is very endurable and it has an awesome finish. I have used it to carry the laptop for short periods (10 to 20 minutes) and it is quite comfortable.
2- Bag for small items
I haven’t found a use for this yet… may be it’s for the mouse and other small peripherals.
3- Power cord
It is 180 cm long from the plug until the transformer, the transfomer measures 15 cm and from it to the laptop input there is 180 cm more of wire, so you get a 375 cm effective length! The cord has a velcro-system to keep it coiled in a hank.
4- Quick start guideThis poster-sized guide shows you how to take your first steps with the laptop. It is pretty graphic and it describes all ports, keys and accessories the laptop has.
5- Detailed manual
It explains more in-depth the networking system, the TDT antenna connection, and other utilities like HP Media Smart and the security system. The best of all this is it comes with a small box where you can place the warranty sheet, invoice and CDs (for drivers or so) so you can keep it all organized.
6- TDT Antenna
To be able to use the integrated TDT card it is necessary that the signal arrives to the laptop. We can get this with the antenna shown that has a cable 150 cm long. I was surprised when I realized that it works better when it’s placed near a wall which is leading a TV cable instead of depending on if the place is higher or not.
7- Antenna adapter
If you prefer to connect the laptop to the TV antenna directly you must use this adapter.
8- Battery
In energy saving configuration it can last 2h 10m approximately. Under demanding conditions (i.e. when gaming) the battery lasts around 1h 20m or less, depending on the load. As I said before, this is not a important point for me and I have not tested different battery saving configurations to ensure how long it lasts… in fact, I work with no battery most of the time.
9- Laptop
Design and finish: Good
This laptop features a modern bluish dark grey with an abstract silver wave pattern.
At first sight the laptop looks like scratched, but later you realise it is a very smart desing. Due to the flash light the colour looks much more bright than it really is and the touchpad lines look white but they have the same bluish dark
grey colour than the rest of the laptop. I apologize for the bad quality of the pictures… the case colour is like the darker colour you can see, only with a strong light you can see finer lines.
The only disadvantage I can find is that, because of the glossy finish, it collects fingerprints very easily.
Sound: Excellent
I have no words to describe the so powerful sound, clear and precise that the HDX 16 delivers. The subwoofer makes shake all around when playing deep basses, but you can adjust its intensity; you can control the trebble too. The volume it can reach is the similar to the one of most TVs.
Screen: Excellent
Another of the HPX 16 wonders is its Full HD screen. When you set brightness to the maximum, or when you work with the laptop plugged to a power outlet, the screen is so bright that any reflection is supressed, allowing a good visualization. However, I must clarify that the screen is glossy and that’s a handicap for those who want to use it outdoors… But I think its sharpness and brightness outweighs that problem because this laptop is not made for use it outdoors.
To tell the truth, I was worried about the Full HD resolution in a 16-inch screen making text and fonts too small. However, when I saw it I was really happy about the large workspace I had: I can have 3 pdf documents in parallel and read them with no problems. Below you can see the size of the menu, but the pictures cannot show how bright the screen is. You can also see a few screenshots.
Viewing angles are very good, the image can get a bit darker an high angles but you can see the image very nicely up to an angle of 179º. Finally, the screen can be opened 135º.
CD/DVD/Blue-ray reader: Good
The combo Blue-Ray+DVD+CD lightscribe reader works as intended. It makes a slightly noise when working but that is usual, isn’t it? I have not tried the DVD/CD burning function yet. A minor detail you should be advised is that when closing the CD reader you must soflty push down or it won’t close. That’s something you easily get used to but it makes the reader not perfect.
Ports and connectivity: Very good.
You can see the port allocation in the following pictures:.
VGA, docking station, Ethernet, HDMI, USB-eSATA, USB, FireWire, ExpressCard 54 (houses the small remote control)
Card reader, mic, 2 audio-out
USB, optical drive, USB, kensington slot, power adapter
As you can see the USB ports are placed on the left and on the right (one of the left is shared with the eSATA port) which allows more flexibility when connecting devices as you wish. The power supply is on the right, with the TDT entry and a couple of USB ports. The rest is on the left. The card reader is on the front-left side and there are two audio outputs and one microphone input on the front right side.
Quick access: Good
On the top of the keyboard you can find some quick access keys: MediaSmart, DVD control (next track, stop/still, open DVD reader,…), mute, volume controller, trebble and bass controller and the WiFi on/off key. The tactile sensibility is good but with a small delay. Although of the most times it is enough with a soft pass of your finger over them, some times you must push stronger. Besides, each time you move up/down the volume a “click” sounds and that sound (PC generated) is not really coordinated with the actual pushing duration, so it can be a little bit annoying sometimes.
NOTE: Now I realize that I cannot use them to control the volume when the OpenOffice is on the foreground! To do it I have to minimize it… that does not happens with other programs such as Interer Explorer or multimedia players.
Temperature and fan: Mediocre
Well, here is when the laptop shows its worst point. Sometimes the temperature rises quickly, specially when the graphic card is working hard. I can distinguish several fan operational modes (up to 6 I guess), but to simplify three can be considered: quiet, medium and turbo. The quiet mode is the most common, when the laptop has been turned on recently and it is working with text, browsing the Net, watching TV and other tasks that does not require a great work for the CPU neither the GPU. The medium mode is the one the laptop uses when is booting or when playing game of medium graphic intensity. The turbo mode is almost an emergency mode: it starts when the vent is blocked, when you overload the GPU and, sometimes, when the laptop is booting: the fan dissipates the heat very effectively but with a strong noise (similar to the sound level of a floppy disk reader).
If you work unplugged the battery gets hot too and the laptop heats up, so I recommend not using the battery unless you do not have any other choice.
The temperature of the area palm rest is slightly higher than your body temperature so you can feel it is warm, but it is not uncomfortable. It should be emphazised that the area below the numeric keyboard is completely cool.
I must thank that the heat vent is on the left side, so if I want to use a mouse I do not feel the heat due to the fact I am right-handed.
Webcam and microphone: Very good
I haven’t tried them very much, but I can say that the image quality is very good and there are some preinstalled applications that allow you to liven up the image in real time.
Fingerprint reader: Very good
Althought I was thinking that the fingerprint reader was a preppy-posh thing, even useless, I have changed my mind and now I use it not only for starting session on Windows faster, but for sign up on different web sites too. It works very well and recognizes your fingerprint instantly.
Keyboard: Very good
The keyboard is very comfortable and you get used to it very soon. Besides, the laptop has a slightly inclination to make more ergonomic the writing position. The size of the gap between keys is quite good and thanks to its numeric keyboard you can write numbers faster. When writing it is possible that you touch the touchpad accidentally, but fortunately there is a key under the spacebar to disable it.
TouchPad: Good
In other reviews, the touchpad has been defined as “too hard”. It is my first laptop so I cannot campare it with any other but, until now, I have not had the need to use a traditional mouse during this month and some days that I have been using the HDX 16. Perhaps it would need more sensibility to go from one part of the screen to the other without lifting the finger (with the maximum sensibility configuration you will need 2.5 passes over the touchpad to cross the screen from left to right completely). The vertical scroll bar is very useful and it works properly: the faster you pass your finger over it, the more you will scroll.
Software: Good
The 64 bits OS Windows Vista Home Premium runs very well and smoothly in this machine. It has preinstalled other applications like Norton Antivirus (Trial Editon), HP Games (Trial Edition) and HP MediaSmart, that is the only really interesting presinstalled application: with it you can play music, see images and photos, watch the TV and DVDs, etc. But there is a problem with the TDT decoder: some times it fails (I think it is a problem with the driver), and you have to reboot the laptop to keep watching the TV. The bug gives a message like “CLCaspSVC Module stopped working”. Another usual bug is the “Pure Networks Module stopped working” but I think the fault is from the router I have at home.
Performance
Here you have the results of 3DMark 06 a 1280×800 and 1920×1080:
I have tried Call of Duty 4, and it is played very smoothly with this configuration:
At 1920×1080 without AA it is also silk smooth.
10- Small remote control
It is a remote control designed for DVD playing, with volume control keys, pause, play, next track, and so on.
11- Large remote control
It is designed for DVD and TV playing. It includes more keys than his smaller brother: channel selection buttons, the “red-green-yellow-blue” keys and other quick start TDT, Windows Media Centre and HP Media Smart keys.
12- Laptop sleeve
It allows you to keep the HDX safe from dust. It would be more useful a stronger case to protect the laptop better.
Conclusions
This laptop has all the requirements I wanted to fulfill and it is a very nice deal for that price. If you want a pretty good laptop which is specialized in multimedia entertainment don’t think it twice.
Most important advantages:
- Screen (and resolution)
- Sound
- Connectivity
- Quality/price
Disadvantages
- Weight
- Temperature
- Battery life
Overall score (taking into account all the factors): 8
Personal score (to reach my goals): 9.5
Some purchase options
Related posts:
- Fast review: Fujitsu-Siemens Amilo Pi 2540
- Dell Studio 15 (1537) review
- Apple Macbook Pro review (15-inch, June 2009 model)
- Laptop reviews: Asus W90, HP HDX 16, Intel Convertible Classmate PC, Toshiba Satellite A355 and others
- Laptop reviews: HP Pavilion HDX 18, Dell Studio 17, Asus G50V, Lenovo Thinkpad X200t and others
Tags: HP, laptop, laptop review, review
Does it have a T/V out?
It has HDMI and VGA as video outputs. If your TV has HDMI port, you can connect it, if not you maybe could get some kind of adapter.
Great review. I’d been considering this HP but went with the Sony Vaio FW390CTO instead (partly because I got a great deal on it – 8 gig ram, 2.66ghz processor, HD screen, Blu ray drive)
My main problems with it are:
a) screen resolution. At the HD native resolution, texts are insanely small. I’ve got 20/20 vision, but after staring at the screen for 15 hours, if feels like my eyes are bleeding. However, when I reduce the resolution it makes everything unacceptably blurry. When I increase the font size, it significantly distorts the layout of most web pages.
Besides, constantly having to switch between a HD picture editing mode, and low res. document writing mode is a major pain.
I’m thinking of returning the laptop and replacing with the HDX, but before I do, I was wondering whether you had to adjust your screen or font size to get the text to the size you showed in your screen shots?
Thanks again for a great review.
As the size and resolution of the screen are the same (1920×1080 in 16″) I think it’s likely that you have the same problem, maybe a 1600×900 resolution would be the best compromise. I’m going to tell the user that contributed this review about your comment, so you can have first-hand info.
Hello John,
the screenshots were taken with the native resolotuion. However you can adjust the resolution to see the fonts higher… for example, with a 1280×800 resolution you will get something like this:
1280×800 –> http://es.tinypic.com/r/2pqt16p/5
1920×1080 –> http://es.tinypic.com/r/15y9erk/5
However, nowdays I will consider the laptop that a friend has recently bought. It is the Asus M70VN (there are two versions, one has a stunning T9400 processor and a 9600 GT GPU and the other has a P8600 processor and a 9650GT GPU). It cost the same (aprox.) than the HDX and my friend says that is going OK for the moment (he bought it 7 days ago).
Hope that helps
Thanks very much for the additional pics, Ogait. Very helpful indeed.
I think I’m sold on the HDX. The little extra touches make it a better package overall. It’s heavier than I’d like, but with the full HD, dazzling screen, number keypad, backlit keyboard, and abundance of ports, I think it’ll serve me better than the more powerful, better looking Sony.
Thanks again for your feedback, and for the great review. Helped cement my decision.
Nice laptop, i should have had bought the 1080p one too. careful though, always use the screen protector for when you closes the lid, with time scratch appears one the screen. For me its exactly where the power button for the mousepad is and a little around it for some its arround the top of the keyboard etc. anyways awesome laptop.
[...] reviews of only two laptops, the Dell Studio 1537 that I purchased for my personal use and the HP HDX16 purchased by our forum mate Ogait. Thanks to the kindness of Apple Spain now I have the opportunity [...]
hi i recently buy a hdx16 1200 premium series, very powerfull notebook.. but the autonomy of my battery its just for 1 h 40 m with wireless and some web pages.. do you think its normal considering the 16″ wide screen ?
Do you use the energy saving power profile? That’s a bit low compared to the model tested here, but I think the 1200 series has a faster card (GT 130M) that could account for a shorter battery life. Watch you CPU usage, if it’s high it’s going to suck more power.
yes mi cpu usage goes between 5-7% i think its not to much , and also i have a gforce gt 9600m graphic card.. maybe thats my energy problem…
tks 4 the reply..
I have been extremely impressed with the HDX 16 I bought back in April. I use it for process modeling using IBM WebSphere Business Modeler and the high definiton and resolution allows me to see 1/3 more of the models. Main drawback is the heat dissipation unless I use it propped up. Last night it blue screened on my after watching a film recorded on media centre which was a little worrying at the time. All seems well today and I have upgraded the bios to see if that improves fan management. I still think it is a great laptop and don’t regret buying it at all.
Great review. My friend has this same laptop that he bought in France. His did not include an antenna adapter like device number 7 in your photo. Please let me know how he can order this antenna adapter. Thanks.
Hello Curt,
I don’t know how your friend can get the antenna adapter. Take a look on e-bay and if you don’t find it I think you can buy it from the HP on-line store.
Hope that helps.
Does anybody know where I can get or purchase the above item 12: Laptop sleeve (in the picture the laptop is inside)?? I have lost mine.
I called HP and the computer stores in Edmonton, Alberta, Canada.
They all said there is no such thing. Idiots.
Hi Emily,
They probably don’t have a Part Number for that, so they can’t find it easily. I have searched in HP Canada for sleeves compatible with the HDX16 and this is what I have found (click “cases and covers”):
http://h10010.www1.hp.com/wwpc/ca/en/ho/WF13a/321957-321957-3806904-3806906-3806906-3769205.html?lang=en&jumpid=oc_R1002_CAENC-002_HP%20HDX%20X16-1056CA%20Premium%20Notebook%20PC&cc=ca
Thanks Felip. But that is not what I want. I want that specific black fabric tote bag with drawstrings that can just fit the laptop in. It came in the original box. Do you know anywhere I can find it or buy it? Thanks.
Yes, I know what you are talking about, but it isn’t in the HP site and you can’t find any part number (it’s not in the Service Guide: http://h10032.www1.hp.com/ctg/Manual/c01612461.pdf), I think it’s very difficult to get, maybe in eBay or in sites selling refurbished HP laptops…
I’m curious about that, why do you prefer the fabric bag to a neoprene (or similar) sleeve?
Well..first of all that was an excellent and informative review..i just sold my HP Compaq laptop and looking to buy HP HDX 16. I was wondering when it is such a perfect device, y is there still a margin in the temperature. My concern here is the Graphics card temperature which is integrated with the motherboard. When i surveyed the market, i got most opinions not to buy a laptop with graphics card because regular use of it will ultimately damage its motherboard. I am double minded now, so any one help me out here.
Well, in 95% of laptops, the graphics card is soldered onto the motherboard, so if the graphics card needs to be replaced, you have to replace the motherboard. But, with a few exceptions, I find perfectly safe to buy and use a laptop with dedicated graphics. The point is to get a laptop that suits your needs: need graphical performance > dedicated graphics, much better if its a model with a good cooling.
As for the HDX16, it’s discontinued in most countries, but if you can find it, avoid the version with the GT 130M graphics card, it seems to be troublesome.
How much will it go for?
That model has been discontinued in most countries, so you’ll be lucky if you can find it.
I have had mine for a year now and I love it. I played WoW on it for a bit and was amazed at how well it handled and I’m a Simmer- plays great with Sims 3. Only down, as mentioned, is battery life and it gets pretty hot. I recommend you purchase a laptop cooling fan to help keep it cool. Unfortunately, for two days now my laptop will shut off without warning once it hits 50% battery power. That’s right when the fan switches over to turbo only it shuts off now. Other then that,I love it. Oh, and if you have any resolution to how to fix this kicking off issue, please let me know.
It’s Vista Home Premium 64-bit
Intel Core Duo T6400 @ 2.00 GHz
4.00 GB of memory
Thanks.
Lexi
Avoid HP laptops at all cost. This laptop and other laptops sold by HP have the volume and WIFI control problems. The volume and WIFI turns on and off by itself rendering the laptop useless. HP tends to ignore the problem but if you search the internet the problem affects dv5, dv7, dv8, HDX16 and HDX 18 and many more current models. Search HP volume problem and you can read numerous unsolved complaints.
No doubt, the specs will make you buy it. However once you get these annoying volume and WIFI pop-ups, you will think differently about HP and the game it plays.
Hey friend I BADLY NEED that wallpaper set on HPX 16 plzzz…. Can someone please mail me it or mail information about where i can get it. Thanks in advance.
My HDX 18 just started the WIFI/Volume problem after owning it for a little over a year. The problem is with the touch sensitive media bar atop the keyboard. Just like JEB says, you can google it and confirm the problems users have with this thing. HP is very much aware of the problem and has had no official statement on the issue as far as I know. I won’t buy another HP laptop.